Does your horse stumble in lessons? Has your trainer told you to tell your farrier to “roll” or “rocker” the toes on your horse’s shoes? Does your horse still stumble? Can your farrier do anything to actually fix it? There are several reasons why a horse may stumble. Before attempting to mechanically “fix” the issue by making changes to your horse’s feet, you must identify the cause of the problem. The following is a comprehensive list of causes that should be considered before modifying your horse’s shoeing or trimming protocol. ## 1. Age and Fitness Level Young horses often stumble in the ongoing process of discovering their own feet and the limits of their movement. Imagine that you are watching a soccer game played by 8-year old children: you would never assume that any child that stumbles needs “corrective” athletic shoes. Stumbling, in a young horse, is simply a normal part of growing. Young horses who have just been started under saddle have to adjust to live weight on their back, as well as their own movement. Unsteady riders paired with unsure horses are a combination that will likely lead to stumbling. As the horse ages and becomes accustomed to carrying live weight, the stumbling will naturally decrease. Fitness level is another important factor to consider. An out-of-shape horse is not just an overweight horse. Out-of-shape horses can be horses that sit in a stall for several weeks, and then are suddenly taken out for a three-day ride. These horses will fatigue quicker, and are at an increased likelihood of stumbling. All of the above are examples of stumbling that do not call for an alteration in the horse’s trimming and/or shoeing protocol. ## 2. Fatigue Fatigue will cause a horse to stumble. In movement, the muscles of the deep digital flexor tendon and the superficial digital flexor tendon stretch and allow the fetlock to sink in a controlled manner. The muscles then contract and pull the fetlock and hoof capsule up onto the toe, in preparation for the anterior (forward) phase of the stride. When the muscles become tired they do not respond as efficiently, and the tendons do not pull the fetlock and hoof on to the toe fast enough. The horse's body weight passes the limb before his foot is ready. The horse throws his feet forward to keep his nose off the ground. Quickly bringing the feet forward means that the feet are kept close to the ground and stumbling may occur. ## 3. Mechanical Lameness Horses that have problems in their knees, fetlock and/or coffin joints will resist movement of the effected joint. In an effort to keep the joint as quiet as possible, the horse will keep his feet close to the ground. This is called "daisy cutting", and it increases the occurrence of stumbling. Watch someone walk with a knee brace. They will make an outward movement with their leg, keeping their foot close to the ground. This is done to bring the leg forward without bending the knee. Similarly, when a horse needs to move its limb forward without flexing a joint, he will move the limb closer to the ground and sometimes outward. ## 4. Upper Fixation of the Patella The stifle is a complex joint that involves the distal (bottom) aspect of the femur, the proximal (top) aspect of the tibia and the patella (our kneecap). The distal aspect of the femur has two ridges (condyles). The patella rests on top of the medial condyle (a large protuberance at the end of some bones) and helps lock the stifle joint, assisting the horse in standing without muscular effort. In movement, the patella effortlessly slides on and off this ridge. When the stifle is injured due to stress, conformation, or accident, the medial patella ligament catches on top of the medial condyle of the femur, momentarily locking the patella. The stifle joint cannot flex, and because the stifle and hock joints are reciprocal joints, the hock doesn't flex either. This causes the horse to stumble. Without a careful examination by a veterinarian this problem is often overlooked. ## 5. Beginning of Lameness Horses that are experiencing the first stage of one of many front feet lameness may alter the way they travel. This can cause the horse to stumble. Heel soreness can be the beginning of several problems of the navicular area or flexor tendon problems. A host of other injuries or soreness’ may cause the horse to land toe first, altering his normal heel first footfall. The toe striking the ground first causes the horse to stumble. ## 6. Rider Error A poor or inexperienced rider can be the origin of stumbling for the horse. It takes years of practice and hard work to properly collect a horse. Since horses naturally carry sixty percent of their weight on the front feet, riders that allow the horse to lay on the bit will create a scenario where the horse gets heavy on the forehand and stumbles as a result of this extra weight. Breakover is delayed as the center of gravity moves forward with speed. Riders who allow the horse to get behind the bit, where the horse curls his head downward, with his nose to his chest, create vision difficulty for the horse as well as allowing thim to focus on getting away from the bit rather than watching where he is going. Riders on a trail ride who allow their horse to walk very close to the horse in front of them will have trouble with stumbling because their horse's view of the ground is obstructed by the other horse. Riders who ride their horses through rough and unfamiliar terrain increase the possibility of stumbling. Excellent riders, who know how to properly collect a horse, will rarely purchase horses with serious conformation flaws which lead to stumbling. Beginners are more likely to purchase inexpensive horses who are more likely to have conformation flaws that lead to a variety of gait abnormalities, including stumbling. The more conformation problems the horse has the better the rider must be to keep the horse in balance. ## 7. Infrequent Trimming and/or Shoeing Schedule Some horses need to be trimmed and shod more frequently than others for a variety of reasons. Once feet get long, gait abnormalities increase, as well as difficulty in breaking over at the toe. If you notice your horse stumbling more and more as the next trimming or shoeing appointment approaches, it is recommended to put the horse on a shorter schedule. ## 8. Lazy Horses Some horses may stumble simply due to their lazy nature. These are the horses that in absence of physical ailments will still drag their feet or barely clear the ground with their toes. Trying to increase breakover or overshortening the toes can actually make the problem worse and lead to more stumbling. Better results may be achieved in this case by applying a heavier shoe, which will encourage the horse to be more aware of his feet. ## 9. Clogged Tear Duct Scott Simpson noted in his book The Identification, Analysis and Correction of Gait Faults in Horses, that horses kept and/or ridden in dusty arenas get their tear ducts clogged with dust. The tear duct originates at the corner of the horse's eye and travels to the inside of his nostrils. When the tear duct becomes clogged, the tears remain in the eye and eventually spill over the eye onto the cheek. With the increase in moisture to the eye, vision becomes blurred and may create a stumbling problem. ## 10. Terrain Any horse will stumble if the terrain is uneven or rocky. Rough, rocky ground with horses that are not used to this type of traveling, cause stumbling. Arena horses out on a rough trail tend to stumble. Increasing breakover will not make a flatland horse into a sure-footed mountain horse. ## 11. Conformation There are certain types of conformation that make a horse predisposed to stumbling. Any conformation that makes the horse heavy on the forehand will create the potential stumble. “Standing under” makes the horse heavy on the forehand, which causes the horse's body weight to pass over the leg too early in the stride. This will cause the horse to throw his leg out in front of him to support his weight. This throwing of his leg keeps the foot close to the ground and predisposes the horse to stumbling. A horse with a “long neck and large head” will be heavy on the front end, and this will cause stumbling. Horses that are built “downhill”, where their croup is higher than the withers, will make them overload the front-end, and cause stumbling The legs of a “pigeon-toed” horse move outward (paddle), making them land on the outside of their hoof with their toes pointing inwards. This can create a situation where the horse stumbles. A “long toe, low heel” foot physiology will cause the horse's body weight to pass over the leg before the leg is prepared to move forward, delaying the breakover. With the body weight in front of the leg, the horse quickly throws his foot forward, keeping it low to the ground and predisposing him to stumble. ## 12. Inner Ear Infection A horse with an inner ear infection tends to hold its head in one direction and sometimes at a slight slant. Either balance is impaired and/or the horse is too occupied with ear problems to pay attention to where he is going. ## 13. Ewe Neck or Swan Neck Horses with ewe or swan necks are what we call star-gazers. These horses travel with their noses straight out and their heads high in the air. Because of their neck conformation, they cannot put their face forward by flexing their necks and arching. Flexing will ‘crimp’ their windpipe, creating difficulty in breathing. Therefore, they hold their heads high, can’t see where they are going, and stumble. ## 14. (BONUS) The Occasional Stumble Stumbling is just a product of movement. It happens to every horse periodically. The occasional stumble is probably not a problem that requires veterinarian or farrier intervention. So... When Should a Horse’s Shoeing and Trimming Protocol Be Modified? Increasing breakover, and rockering or rolling the toes of a horseshoe, will seldom make a difference to fix your horse’s stumbling, especially if your horse is already on a regular schedule with an experienced farrier. The only instances where shoeing modifications may be beneficial, is in the case of long toe-low heel conformations, specifically where a long toe may not be safely trimmed back without risking laming the horse. In these cases, breakover must be brought back with the mechanics of the shoe. If your horse’s toes are at an appropriate length, and you are experiencing excessive stumbling, further increasing breakover is unlikely to solve the problem. Make sure you consider all possibilities before modifying your horse’s hoof care protocol.